NASCAR Legends’ Worst Season in Their PRIME

HOMESTEAD, FL - NOVEMBER 14: Jeff Gordon driver of the #24 DuPont Chevrolet during qualifying for the NASCAR Sprint Cup Series Ford 400 at Homestead-Miami Speedway on November 14, 2008 in Homestead, Florida. (Photo by Robert Laberge/Getty Images for NASCAR)

What’s Happening?

NASCAR is a hard sport to win races in, and it is even harder to win Championships. Even some of the sports’ best drivers stumble during their prime. This is not simply their worst seasons though, but we are specifically looking at the era when they were thought to be at the top of their game. These are some of NASCAR legends’ worst seasons in their prime.

You Need to Know:

  • For this list, we will focus on when these legends were in the prime of their racing career. Many of these drivers’ worst statistical seasons came at the end of their careers when they were clearly on a downward trend.
  • In order for a season to be counted on this list, the driver must have either won multiple races or a Championship in at least three separate seasons before OR following the season listed. Therefore, entries like any Richard Petty season pre-1963 or post-1981 are ineligible.
  • Fans love to look back on the greatest moments drivers ever had. However, not every season is a fond memory for fans or drivers alike.

Richard Petty 1978

Heading into 1978, Richard Petty was on a hot streak. He finished in the top-2 in points in 6 of the previous 7 seasons with 4 Championships. It seemed Championship number 7 was destined to happen soon, but, 1978 was not the year for Petty.

He failed to win a race for the first time since 1959, his rookie season. He finished outside of the top-5 in points for the first time in a full season since 1961. He also had 12 DNFs, which was the most he had since NASCAR’s “Modern Era” began in 1972. It was so bad, that Petty switched from longtime manufacturer, Chrysler, to General Motors late in the season to slightly better results.

1979 proved that 1978 was just a fluke as Petty won 5 races and his 7th Cup Series Championship. He won multiple races in 5 of the next 6 seasons between 1979 and 1984. He was still capable of winning races, but, 1978 was an off-year.

Dale Earnhardt 1992

Between 1986 and 1994, Dale Earnhardt won 6 Championships and 48 races. He was unstoppable, except in 1992. While NASCAR was mired in its’ greatest Championship battle, “The Intimidator” was nowhere to be found.

Despite a rocky start, Earhnhardt won the Coca-Cola 600, and he was second in points before Pocono in June. Four engine failures over the rest of the season, including three in five races, was what did Earnhardt in. He fell all the way to 12th in the standings to finish the year.

After the year, longtime crew chief Kirk Shelmerdine left the team. Andy Petree came in, and Earnhardt was back on track in 1993. He won Championships in 1993 and 1994, and he finished second in 1995 before Petree left.

Jeff Gordon 2008

Jeff Gordon narrowly missed out on the Championship in 2007 despite 6 wins and 30 Top-10s. Hendrick Motorsports seemed to have the edge with the “Car of Tomorrow”, so, Gordon was expected to do the same in 2008. Not everything worked out as planned.

He failed to finish two of the first three races, despite leading laps in all three. A crash at Las Vegas set the tone for the rest of his season. He was not terrible in 2008, but, for the first time since his rookie season in 1993, he failed to win a race.

This set Gordon on a tough stretch where he only won 1 race between 2008 and 2010. However, he was back on track with 3 wins in 2011, and he nearly won his fifth Championship in 2014 and 2015 before retiring,

Tony Stewart 2008

While Tony Stewart’s 2006 season is the bad one many remember, 2008 was statistically worse. He had a worse average finish, fewer top-5s, fewer top-10s, and fewer wins. His only win came in October at Talladega after Regan Smith was penalized for passing Stewart below the yellow line.

Matters were made worse when Stewart announced he was moving on from Joe Gibbs Racing in the middle of the season to become an owner-driver at the new “Stewart-Haas Racing”. It was just a disappointing season with many distractions.

By 2009, Stewart was back to form in the 14-car with 4 wins. In 2011, he won his third Cup Series Championship. Maybe the distractions in 2008 caused the issues for Stewart, but, still, it was a puzzling season for him.

Kevin Harvick 2012

Between 2010 and 2021, Kevin Harvick finished outside of the top-5 in points only twice. The worst of that bunch was 2012. Coming off of two consecutive third-place points finishes in 2010 and 2011, Harvick seemed poised for another great season.

He remained winless throughout much of the season until Phoenix in November. He only led laps in 8 of the 36 races, and he hit his biggest snag between the late summer and early fall. Between Indianapolis and Martinsville, Harvick had only 2 top-10s in 14 races, and he was out of the Championship running early in the Playoffs.

By 2013, Harvick was back in the top-3 in points, and he won a Championship in 2014. He became one of the most dominant drivers in the sport throughout the 2010s, but, 2012 was the one year he was basically a nonfactor.

What was the worst season for your favorite driver? Did it come during the prime of their career?

Share this:

HAMPTON, GEORGIA - FEBRUARY 21: Sheldon Creed, driver of the #00 Road Ranger Chevrolet, takes the checkered flag to win the NASCAR O'Reilly Auto Parts Series Bennett Transportation & Logistics 250 at Echo Park Speedway on February 21, 2026 in Hampton, Georgia.

O’Reilly: Sheldon Creed Breaks Through in Thriller at EchoPark Speedway

What’s Happening?

It was a busy Saturday at EchoPark Speedway (formerly Atlanta Motor Speedway). First, we had the NASCAR Craftsman Truck Series race. Then, the O’Reilly Auto Parts Series took center stage and they were two vastly different events. Ultimately, it was Sheldon Creed standing tall in victory lane when all was said and done. Here’s what you need to take away from tonight’s NASCAR O’Reilly Auto Parts Series race at EchoPark Speedway.

  • There were a lot of drivers who had tire problems which set off massive wrecks and incidents. First, Sam Mayer had a tire go down from the race lead. Sammy Smith got bitten. Austin Green. Corey Day. Taylor Gray. The list goes on and on. Some of them were able to stay in contention while others were plagued for the rest of the race.
  • Speaking for Corey Day, he just had a bad race. First, he sparked an incident which took out several drivers, including the Sieg brothers (who weren’t shy about voicing their displeasure about the rookie) and Harrison Burton. And though the broadcasters on the CW gave him the benefit of the doubt, the later incident was less forgivable. In this incident, while he was battling the JRM duo of Carson Kvapil and Justin Allgaier for the race lead, Day got into the No. 1 Arby’s Chevy, sending all three of them into the wall. This is certainly a performance that he’ll want to forget.
  • Chevrolets swept the stages. Winning the first one was none other than Jesse Love, continuing RCR’s dominance on drafting tracks. Rajah Caruth, who had a handful all race, was able to capture his first career stage win by winning Stage 2.
  • It wasn’t the dominating race for RCR that we all thought it would be. With ill-handling cars, their qualifying attempts were underwhelming, and they got off to a lukewarm start tonight. By the end of it, though, they were in the mix. Slicing and dicing, Austin Hill had the lead as they came around to take the white flag. However, in Turn 1, he got “Chastained.” Ross Chastain plowed into the back of the No. 21, knocking him down to the apron. Hill was able to save it and rally home to a 12th place finish.
  • The big story tonight is that Sheldon Creed, finally, after far too many runner-up finishes to count, broke through to capture his first NASCAR O’Reilly Auto Parts Series win. It will certainly be a day he and his team will never forget.

Notable Incidents

Lap 5: Corey Day

Corey Day had a very sloppy, bad race in general, and it started early. First, he caused a wreck that took out Harrison Burton and a couple of others. Then, he took out the JRM duo of Carson Kvapil and Justin Allgaier. You can recap that first incident by reading the article below.

Also Read:

Lap 142: Sammy Smith

Kvapil and Allgaier weren’t the only JRM cars to have issues tonight. Firstly, Rajah Caruth was out of control throughout the race, fighting a mean-handling car. He was able to brilliantly save it several times, to his credit. But perhaps the biggest incident involving the four JRM Chevys came at Lap 142 when Sammy Smith had a tire go down and spun in front of the pack. This took out several drivers, including Taylor Gray, among others. Read about that here:

Also Read:

Results

Results Pending.

Points Standings (2 of 35)

What do you think about this? Let us know your opinion on Discord or X. Don’t forget that you can also follow us on InstagramFacebook, and YouTube.

O’Reilly: Sammy Smith’s Flat Takes Out Heavy Hitters Late at EchoPark

What’s Happening?

As Ross Chastain took the lead and the pack was closing in on 20 laps to go, things a little deeper in the pack started to get a little hairy. We had yet another huge crash late in the running here tonight, this one sparked by Sammy Smith’s flat rear tire. Here’s what happened:

  • As the laps were winding down in tonight’s O’Reilly Auto Parts Series race, Sammy Smith, along with his JRM teammates, were in the thick of contention for the win. Unfortunately for him, a poorly-timed flat rear tire ended his (and several others) chance to capitalize and get that first valuable win of the season. Unable to hold onto it, the No. 8 Pilot Chevy spun around in front of a massive horde of cars.
  • Helpless to go anywhere, several heavy hitters were caught up in this incident. They include the likes of William Sawalich, Gio Ruggiero, Patrick Staropoli, Taylor Gray, Brennan Poole, Nick Leitz, and Lavar Scott.
  • It’s an unfortunate beginning of the year for a handful of these drivers. Luckily for Brennan Poole, he’s coming off a strong showing at Daytona and was in the thick of it here tonight. That shows some promise for sure.

What do you think about this? Let us know your opinion on Discord or X. Don’t forget that you can also follow us on InstagramFacebook, and YouTube.

O’Reilly: Mid-Race Report from EchoPark Speedway

What’s Happening?

It has been a tail of two races when it comes to today’s NASCAR O’Reilly Auto Parts Series at EchoPark Speedway (formerly the Atlanta Motor Speedway). We got off to a rough start with Corey Day triggering a massive wreck that took out the likes of Harrison Burton, and the Sieg brothers. Then, the field settled in and started to churn laps. Here’s what’s gone down so far.

  • Sam Mayer led a bulk of the opening laps. Leading the first 23 laps of the race, he was forced to pit on Lap 24 due to a flat left front tire. No caution was triggered. To make matters worse, he was caught speeding on pit road, putting him down several laps and effectively taking him out of contention.
  • Jesse Love continued RCR’s dominance in the first stage. With Mayer out of the picture, he assumed the race lead, leading 31 laps to win the opening stage.
  • Austin Hill finally made it up to the race lead by Stage 2. Unfortunately for him and RCR, their win streak in the stages ended with the conclusion of Stage 2. It was Rajah Caruth in the No. 88 HendrickCars.com Chevy that captured the green and white checkered flag.
  • In a horrific accident during pit stops, Taylor Gray smashed into one of his tire carriers. It was a scary situation. Fortunately, he got up like a champ and completed the stop. He was thankfully checked and released from the in-field care center.
  • Corey Day’s woes continued as the field set in for the final stage of the evening. Drawing further criticism, Day, while battling for the race lead, made contact with leader Carson Kvapil, sending them both into the outside wall. Also collected in the incident was Kvapil’s teammate, the 2024 series champion, Justin Allgaier.

What do you think about this? Let us know your opinion on Discord or X. Don’t forget that you can also follow us on InstagramFacebook, and YouTube.