NASCAR Fans React to Controversial No Penalty Ruling After Chicagoland

What’s Happening?

NASCAR’s decision not to penalize Shane van Gisbergen following his incident with Austin Hill at Chicagoland Speedway has sparked widespread debate among fans, many of whom questioned whether the sanctioning body applied its standards consistently.

Preece did the same thing at Texas and got docked 25 points which has kind of ruined his season I better see the same thing happen to SVG sometime this week https://t.co/KffGZGLhqo

— Bread 🙂 (@CEOofBread21) July 6, 2026

The controversy began during Sunday’s Cup Series race when SVG made contact with Austin Hill’s No. 33 Richard Childress Racing Chevrolet. The hit sent Hill spinning backward into the outside wall, inflicting race-ending damage just 47 laps into the 267-lap event.

Hill’s afternoon ended with a disappointing 37th-place finish, marking his second DNF in the last three races. The RCR driver made his frustration clear almost immediately. While running on the apron under caution after heading to pit road, he sideswiped SVG, an incident that also went without a penalty.

Although visibly disappointed after being released from the infield care center, Hill stopped short of accusing SVG of intentionally wrecking him, admitting he had no way of knowing whether the move was retaliation for their previous run-ins.

SVG, meanwhile, downplayed suggestions that the contact was deliberate. While apologizing for the outcome, he laughed off the idea that he had intentionally retaliated, instead pointing out that Hill had played a role in several of their recent incidents.

However, the tension between the two drivers did not begin at Chicagoland. Two weeks ago, at the San Diego street race, Hill made contact with SVG’s Trackhouse teammate Connor Zilisch while battling for the lead, triggering a multi-car crash that eliminated both Trackhouse entries and significantly damaged SVG’s playoff hopes.

The week before that, the duo had also been involved in contact at Pocono Raceway after Hill slid up exiting Turn 3. Their rivalry stretches back even further, dating to the ARCA Menards Series in 2024.

Richard Childress was convinced the Chicagoland contact was connected to those earlier incidents. Speaking over the No. 33 team’s radio, the NASCAR Hall of Fame team owner described the move as “payback for California,” referencing the San Diego race that left both Trackhouse cars out of contention.

Despite the growing speculation, NASCAR ultimately decided there was insufficient evidence to issue a penalty.

Explaining the decision on the Hauler Talk podcast, NASCAR Vice President of Racing Communications Mike Forde said officials conducted an extensive review that included every available camera angle, in-car footage, and team radio communication. According to Forde, NASCAR specifically searched for anything that would indicate the incident had been premeditated, such as radio messages suggesting retaliation.

After reviewing all available evidence, officials concluded there was sufficient uncertainty about the contact to determine it was not intentional. Forde explained that while previous penalties handed to drivers like Ryan Preece and Denny Hamlin were supported by radio transmissions or other clear evidence of intent, no similar “smoking gun” existed in van Gisbergen’s case.

Without eliminating that reasonable doubt, NASCAR determined the incident did not rise to the level of a points or behavioral penalty.

That explanation, however, did little to satisfy many fans.

One fan responded directly to a NASCAR video highlighting the incident, comparing the incident to one that resulted in a penalty for Ryan Preece earlier this season.

“Preece did the same thing at Texas and got docked 25 points which has kind of ruined his season. I better see the same thing happen to SVG sometime this week,” the fan wrote, arguing that the two incidents deserved identical treatment.

Although NASCAR chose not to penalize either driver, the matter is far from over.

SVG, Hill, and two other drivers not involved in the incident are still scheduled to meet with NASCAR officials ahead of this weekend’s race at EchoPark Speedway. Forde emphasized that the purpose of the meeting is preventative, not disciplinary, with officials hoping to ensure the rivalry does not escalate into a more serious issue over the coming weeks.

The Trackhouse Racing driver currently stands 14th in the Cup Series standings with 437 points, holding only a narrow advantage over the playoff cut line. Avoiding a penalty preserved that position and kept his postseason hopes intact heading into a critical stretch of the regular season.

What do you think about this? Let us know your opinion on Discord or X. Don’t forget that you can also follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and YouTube.