The 2008 Amp Energy 500 may be one of if not the most controversial races ever with possibly the most controversial finish ever to a NASCAR race. With the unpopular double line rule the race at the Talladega Superspeedway fans would see an underdog winner in Regan Smith lose their first win in a way that many saw as unfair and possibly biased by popularity with the win ultimately going to Tony Stewart. So who got it? Stewart, Smith, or another? Was this the most controversial NASCAR finish? Regan Smith’s stolen win.